H5P Evaluation (Guideline) Checklist

Submitted by parm27 on Tue, 01/31/2023 - 18:25
parm27's picture
Forums: 
OER Hub

I created an H5P Evaluation (Guideline) Checklist to help ensure good quality H5P OERs. I haven’t done a formal pilot of the tool. If anyone is interested in trying it out, I would love to get some feedback on it, so I can improve it. Here are some questions I have about it:

• Does this checklist work as a guideline for creating interactions?
• Does this document function as checklist to ensure quality?
• How many interactive types have you tested it on?
• How many interactions in total have you tested it on?
• Was there anything criteria that did not make sense?
• Any suggestions for improvement?

Parm

Friedrichowicz

Wed, 02/01/2023 - 11:22

Thank you, Parm, for this comprehensive checklist! I am reviewing literature on quality evaluation of learning objects at the moment, so I am very interested in this.
I  have a general question: Is this intended for a self-check (I rate my own resources) or for peer-review? Or both? I assume it is for self-check as there are some questions that would be difficult to answer for an external reviewer, like the questions on pedagogical fit. I like that these important questions are right at the beginning!
For some items I would need a short explanation, especially for those in the "visual design" section. For the final version of the checklist, I would imagine links to H5P resources for those items that might need some explanation for some people :)

Maria Klar

parm27's picture

parm27

Tue, 02/07/2023 - 17:54

Hi Maria,

Thanks for taking time to look at the checklist and I appreciate your feedback. I reached out to get feedback from different perspectives on this because I believe this version is trying to be all things: a guideline for creating interactive contents, a production checklist, as well as an OER evaluation list. Intially, I included more detail, but I recieved feedback that the document itself was too long. I agree that if it's too long, it might not be as usable. Right now, I'm leaning towards splitting this into 2 or 3 more useable tools.

Thanks again for your help,

Parm

 

otacke's picture

otacke

Thu, 02/02/2023 - 09:41

For others who are interested in this topic, please see https://connect.oeglobal.org/t/oer-h5p-evaluation-guideline-checklist-feedback-requested/4607 where there are more replies already.

Hint for cross-posters: If you don't want discussions to spread across different sites without any connection and if you don't want people (whose resources you are using!) to tell you the same things in different places, decide for one site and just share the links elsewhere, please!