Incorrect grading in Quiz

Submitted by AlonM on Sun, 07/08/2018 - 11:31
Forums: 
Bugs in content types

Hi,

In the attached H5P quiz, questions 1-3 grade correctly: one mark is given for each of two missing numbers, to give a total of 2 per question.
The correct responses (in order) are 2:1, 3:1 and 5:3

The problems are with the last two questions:

Question 4: This is a hypothesis entry, hence I have set all three droppables to be the 'correct answer' for all three drop-zones, while setting each drop-zone to only accept one droppable. I have also set 'one point for the whole task'. Hence, my intent was for students to score 1/1 regardless of their choices. What is happening instead, is that the three individual choices themselves are marked correct regardless of where they are dropped, but the overall mark for the question is always 0/1. I don't know whether this is a bug, or something I did wrong.

Question 5: This is the same question, but here there ARE correct answers after students have tested it out (1st goes with 24:8, 2nd goes with 24:12, and 3rd goes with 20:12). Again, if done right the individual choices themselves are marked correct, but the overall mark for the question is 3/6 rather than 3/3. I don't know where the extra 3 possible marks are coming from. Again, not sure if this is a bug or something I did wrong.

This is being played out on Moodle, on a PC desktop, in Chrome.
Not sure how to check the H5P plugin version or the version of the Quiz module I am using, as plugin installations are managed by our Moodle-partner LMS provider and we do not have access.

Any help would be appreciated.

Thank you,

Alon

H5P file: 
Binary Data experiment-two-quiz-version-14.h5p
BV52's picture

BV52

Mon, 07/09/2018 - 05:54

Hi Alon,

I'm not sure how you created the Drag and Drop activities but everything is working fine in my test content. This could be related to the issue I reported here.

Here are the steps that I followed in creating the content:

  1. Created the text instructions.
  2. Added the images
  3. Added the text labels
  4. Added the draggables
  5. Added the drop drop zones
  6. Edited the draggables to indicate which dropzones it can be dropped, in this case I chose all drop zones
  7. Edited the drop zones to indicate that all draggables are correct answers.
  8. Changed the behavioural settings

Note: I created 2 version one is a stand alone DnD and the other a Quiz (Question Set). In both instances I followed the steps above and both are working as intended.

I assume that both activities can be resolved by following the steps I provided. I would also like to ask if you may have enabled one of the images or text as labels as a draggable (chose a drop zone) as this seems to be the trigger to the issue as stated in the bug report above?

I hope this helps if you are still encountering an issue feel free to post in the forums.

-BV52

AlonM

Tue, 07/10/2018 - 07:03

Hi BV52,

Thank you yet again for your prompt help. I read the bug report, then went in and had a look and could not find any evidence for any of the images or text being set as draggables, then again, I may have done so then immediately disabled it, in which case it seems doing so still leaves a draggable id in the system.

Either way, I carefully recreate the questions exactly according to the order you listed, and the problem was resolved in both of them. So thank you.

Now I have a NEW, somewhat unrelated issue: prior to seeing your response, I thought the error might be related to the Quiz content module version, so I updated it when prompted to. After doing so, the only two questions types that are available to me in any NEW Quiz that I create are DnD and MC.... no more fill-in-the-blank, mark the words, drag text or T/F. Is this intentional? Have those question types been moved elsewhere? Or is this a bug - in which case, surely I'm not the first to report it..... For the moment, I'm resorting to duplicating older quizzes made with the previous version, as this is the only way I can access those other question types.

Thanks,

Alon

BV52's picture

BV52

Tue, 07/10/2018 - 07:16

Hi Alon,

This is known issue but no resolution yet. There is however a workaround this is by downloading a Quiz (Question Set) from H5P.org that has all the content types in it. Luckily I have one readily available and you can download it here.

-BV52